New York Steak with Cherry Wine Sauce

New York steak Recipe
When it is cold outside you just want to bundle up indoors and cook something to warm you up from the inside. In the last few weeks we have been busy with the launch of our new website and since it was a stormy weekend we decided to make a satisfying but simple New York Steak recipe. We first made this recipe a few years back, to pair with Castiglion del Bosco Brunello di Montalcino from the Italian fashion house of Ferragamo. Sorting our photos we found these of the steak and also took a few from the video to share with you so you don’t have to watch the whole video for the recipe.

New York Steak raw

Steak Judit Corina WineDineDaily

New York Steak Dinner Steps

There are many special occasions when we like to express ourselves with a beautiful meal. A well planed and prepared dish, like a New York Steak, helps us to enjoy the process as well and it does not have to be really complicated to be impressive. This steak recipe is like a miracle in our recipe repertoire, something you can prepare in less than 45 minutes. If you want to make an ordinary steak recipe into an extra ordinary dinner then make this cherry wine reduction sauce with its intoxicating effect (especially if you add a little more cherry liquor to it).

New York Steak Wine

The “New York Steak” is one of the juiciest and tenderest pieces of beef, and you may know it as Ambassador, Hotel or even Kansas steak depending on where you live. Ever since we moved to the US we always appreciated a delicious steak dinner and we were both eager to master this culinary marvel. We had several memorable steak dinners in the Big Apple but never visited the famous Delmonaco’s. The history of “New York Steak” goes way way back to 1837 when Delmonico’s Restaurant in Manhattan became America’s first fine dining establishment. Charles Ranhofer the resident French chef delighted his customers with his unique dishes, one of them the Steak Delmonico a tender cut of richly marbled steak which he then sautéed in very hot skillets. Because this city is the hometown of this steak, it is referred to s a New York Strip Steak and there you have it in case you ever wanted to know this juicy tidbit of steak history.

Steak Cooking Rosemary Judit


Brunello wine Ferragamo Steak JuditWhen you are choosing a steak from your butcher or from the meat section at your grocery store, look for tiny white flecks and lines throughout because this glorious marbling will give you the best flavor. The secret to good steak is to start with hot pan. You can prepare the mashed potatoes in advance and just reheat it by stirring with a little added milk before serving. This step will give you plenty of time put on a smashing dress and freshen up your make-up (we all need this after slaving over the hot stove..)

New York steak Recipe

New York Steak with Cherry Wine Sauce

Judit + Corina


  • 2 New York Beef Loin Steak
  • Salt and freshly crushed Pepper Corns
  • 1 Tbsp Olive Oil
  • 2-3 Sprigs of Rosemary
  • 1 cup Red Wine like Sangiovese or Chianti
  • ½ cup Dried Cherries
  • 2 Tbsp Unsalted Butter


  • Season the steaks with salt and crushed pepper and massage in the olive oil. Let the meat rest for at least 30 minutes.
  • Heat a heavy iron pan over medium-high heat and add the marinated steaks to the pan. Do not touch it for 3-4 minutes. If you steak is over ¾ inch thick then leave to sear for 5 minutes.
  • With a thong turn the steaks and season with more salt and pepper. Let it cook for another 3 to 4 minutes.
  • Remove the steaks to a plate and cover with Aluminum Foil and let it rest for 10 minutes.
  • Carefully pour the red wine into steak pan and with a wooden spoon scrape all off the goodness from the bottom of the pan. Add the dried cherries and cook for 5 minute over high heat until the wine is reduced and the sauce is getting thicker. With your rosemary wand gently stir the butter into the sauce. Now if you like you can add a shot of Cherry Liquor and with the rosemary wand continue to stir for a few more minutes so the flavor of the rosemary can infuse this divine sauce.
  • Serve over mashed potatoes or polenta.
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!


New York Steak Wine

Creamy Mashed Potatoes

Judit + Corina


  • 2 Lb Potatoes – peeled and cut into small cubes
  • Sea Salt
  • ½ cup Milk 2%
  • ½ cup Half & Half
  • 4 Tbsp Butter
  • Freshly ground Black Pepper


  • Cook the potato cubes in generously salted water for 20 minutes or until potatoes become tender. Just poke with a fork and if the fork comes out easily then the potatoes are done.
  • Turn off heat and with a potato masher mash the potatoes.
  • Add the milk and butter and continue to punch down until potatoes become creamy.
  • Add freshly ground black pepper and more salt if needed.
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!


If you would like to know how to make a really romantic steak dinner with a smooth and sexy wine reduction sauce then feel free to pour a glass of red wine, sit back and click on the video button down below. We all need one special steak recipe and this elegant New York steak, smothered with a Cherry Wine Reduction sauce, is as divine as it sounds. And on the side there is nothing more delicious then creamy mashed potatoes and gently blanched green beans. We keept the side dishes simple so you can fully taste the steak and sauce.

Wine Pairing: If you can find a Brunello that would be heavily, otherwise a Sangiovese, like the Stolpman Estate Sangiovese, would do or an Italian Chinati with cherry and plum flavors to really harmonize with your steak and sauce. We paired our steak with a Castiglion del Bosco Brunello di Montalcino from Italy.


Tags from the story
, ,
More from Judit + Corina
Quest for Liquid Gold
Quest for Liquid Gold Join us on our “Quest for Liquid Gold”...
Read More
Join the Conversation


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. Boy Howdy, I feel I have a found a ‘home’ with this blog. I live in Washington—on the west side of the
    mountains, but as you probably know we have quite a developed wine industry in our state too. I have spent time east of the mountains enjoying those wineries and developing my palate. I am going to royally enjoy your comments, recipes, photos.

  2. says: Todd

    I’m definitley a meat and potato kind of guy and this steak with wine sauce looks and sounds fantastic! Nice job on the video too.

  3. says: Juliana

    This steak sounds and looks delicious…cherry wine…yes! What a beautiful meal…love the pictures!
    Have a great weekend Judit and Corina 😀

  4. Wow! Fabulous recipe, ladies. My favorite steak is New York Strip Steak. And, you know how much I adore cherry wine sauce! 😉 I love it on ice cream sundaes and just know I would enjoy it with a perfectly prepared New York Strip Steak. Loved all the tips and the video of you two as well. 🙂 Thanks for sharing and have a wonderful weekend. Cheers!

    1. Thank you for your kind words Stacy! So glad you enjoy cherry wine sauce too and now we are looking forward to drizzle it over ice cream. It would be a fitting dessert after the steak with no extra work at all. Hope you had a lovely weekend as well:)

  5. Great reminder that impressive doesn’t have to mean complicated. wonderful idea to pair steak with cherries! My husband would probably enjoy that. He’s much more of a meat-eater than I am so I should probably surprise him with a really meaty meal one day … or get him to make it for me! (maybe that’s the way to go!)

    1. Thank you Helen, glad you like the addition of cherries. The dried cherries give it a nice tangy flavors and if you prefer to omit the wine you could even make this with a nice cherry juice instead of the wine. What a great idea to make him cook the steak for you!

  6. says: Barbara

    What a nice touch to add a cherry wine sauce! I have to try it and make it for a romantic dinner for my boyfriend this weekend. Do you think a Washington Pinot Noir would be good for the sauce?